by myuser.ai
Get it free on Shopify or Wix
Watching replays

Session Recording Checklist for Your First 20 Replays

Your first replays can feel like noise. Use this checklist of what to look for, from menus to forms, and log each finding in a sheet you can act on.

A checklist card titled Your first 20 replays with three of four items ticked (spread visits across days, mix short and long visits, star the clearest replay) and Log each finding still open, beside a list of visits, each guest named Visitor and a short code, where a star is being clicked on the top row.
On this page
  1. Pick 20 visits
  2. Before you open the first one
  3. What should you look for in session recordings?
  4. What to skip
  5. Give each finding a type
  6. Log findings in one place
  7. Turn 20 replays into three fixes
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Try it on your site
  10. Sources

For your first 20 session recordings, pick visits from different days and times, watch each one for trouble in seven areas (navigation, search, product pages, the cart, phones, forms and errors), and log every finding as one row in a spreadsheet. Then sort the rows by how often each problem repeats, and fix the top three before you watch more.

The first time you open a list of recordings, it's hard to know what you're looking at. Every visit seems interesting and none of them adds up. A checklist gives each replay a job, and you finish with a short list of specific things to fix.

Key takeaways

  • Pick 20 visits from different days and times, and include short ones: a visit that ends early often says more than a long one.
  • Watch with seven groups of checks in mind (navigation, search, product pages, cart, phones, forms and errors) and skip what doesn't apply.
  • Log each finding in one row: the visit's date and start time, the moment in the replay, the page, a type and a repeat count.
  • Sort by repeat count, favor problems closer to the sale, and fix the top three before you watch more.

Pick 20 visits

Twenty is small enough to finish in a sitting or two and large enough to show repeats.

  • Spread them out. Take visits from different days of the week and different times of day. A Saturday morning shopper and a Tuesday lunchtime one can behave very differently.
  • Mix short and long. The list shows each visit's length, so include some under a minute alongside longer ones. Don't pick only the longest: a long, happy visit tells you less than a short one that stopped.
  • Don't worry about phones yet. The list marks each visit Mobile or Desktop, and a phone visit plays back in the phone's shape. If your analytics (Shopify's Sessions by device report, or Wix's Traffic Overview) shows that most visitors use mobile and your first ten replays were all desktop, open a few more.

If the list holds far fewer visits than your analytics counts, see why some visits aren't recorded before you start.

Tip: No visits yet? The empty Replays page in Session Recordings has a Watch a sample replay button, a made-up visit to a demo shop. The session replay examples show six common patterns with their Activity lists.

Before you open the first one

  • Open a blank spreadsheet with the columns described further down, so logging takes seconds.
  • Write down anything you changed in the last month, like a new banner, a price change or a new menu. It helps you tell new problems from old ones.
  • Keep your own site open in another tab, so you can click what the visitor clicked.
  • Decide which pages matter most, such as your best-selling product or your booking page, and give them extra attention.

Moving through each replay quickly is a separate skill, with its own speeds, shortcuts and stopping rule: see how to watch session recordings without losing hours. And if you're still choosing a recording tool, here are session recording tools for Wix, side by side.

What should you look for in session recordings?

Look for moments when a visitor hunts, gets stuck or gets pulled away: menu sections opened and closed without a choice, searches that miss, clicks on things that aren't links, carts and forms left behind, taps that miss on phones, and errors. Keep the seven groups below in mind as you watch. You don't need to tick every box on every visit. Note what you see and move on.

  • Where the visitor lands, and whether their first click makes sense from there
  • Menu sections opened and closed without a click inside, a sign of hunting
  • Clicks on headings, photos or icons that aren't links
  • Quick trips back and forth between two pages
  • Whether visitors search at all, and from which page
  • A visit to your Search Results page followed straight away by another search, which means the first one missed
  • Searches that end the visit

What site searches tell you about your visitors goes further.

Product pages

  • How far down the page the visitor scrolls before deciding
  • Which photos they look at, and whether they tap one expecting a bigger view
  • Whether they reach the Add to Cart button at all
  • Trips from the product page to shipping, returns or a size guide

Cart

  • Visits that reach your cart page and end there
  • Quantities changed or items removed
  • Trips from the cart to other pages, such as the shipping policy

Phones

  • Anything covering the page, such as a banner, a pop-up or a chat button
  • Taps that miss their target, or several taps on one spot
  • Bars at the top and bottom that leave the product a narrow strip

Forms

  • Typing (masked) rows: fields typed in, then the visit moves on without the form being sent
  • Fields tapped and left empty
  • A Send click followed by the same page, which can mean an error the visitor had to hunt for
A replayed contact form with the name, email and message typed as asterisks, beside a cookie banner
What visitors type into form fields shows as asterisks, so you see where someone stopped without seeing what they wrote.

Errors

  • Error messages on the page
  • A Click row with a ×N count and no change on the page
  • A visit that ends right after something goes wrong
Session Recordings

Find the moments worth watching

Jump to any moment from the Activity list, skip the quiet parts, watch at up to 8x and star the replays worth keeping.

What to skip

  • Visits of a few seconds with one click and nothing after it
  • Your own visits and your team's. They're recorded like anyone's, so skip the ones from times you were testing the site.
  • One-off oddities you can't explain after a second look. Put them on a short "maybe" list and see if they come back.

Give each finding a type

The type points to the kind of fix it needs.

TypeWhat it looks likeWhat to do next
BugSomething broken, like a button that does nothingTurn it into a bug report
ConfusionSeveral tries to do one simple thingRename, move or simplify the element
Missing infoThe visitor leaves the page to look for an answerPut the answer where they looked first
DistractionSomething pulls attention away from the taskDelay, shrink or remove it

Some findings fit two types. A pop-up whose close button sits off the screen is both a distraction and a bug. Pick the type that points to the fastest fix.

Log findings in one place

Use one spreadsheet row per finding. A replay can produce several rows, or none.

  1. Visit: the date and start time, as the replay list shows them
  2. Moment: the time in the replay
  3. Page
  4. Device: phone or computer, from the shape it plays back in
  5. Type, from the table above
  6. What happened, in one sentence
  7. Count: how many replays showed it

A finished row reads like this.

October 3, 2:14 PM · 0:48 · jacket product page · phone · Missing info · Opened the size guide twice, then left for the FAQ page · seen in 3

Star the replay behind each new row. Starred replays are kept past the usual 30 days, and the Starred tab brings them back, so the evidence is there when you or a teammate need it. When a later replay shows the same thing, add one to the count on the existing row instead of starting a new one.

Turn 20 replays into three fixes

After the 20th replay, sort the sheet by count. A problem that shows up in six visits matters more than one that shows up once. If two tie, start with the one closer to the sale: a snag in the cart costs you more than one on your About page.

Pick the top three. For each, write the fix in one sentence and decide who does it. Bugs go to whoever maintains the site, or the app's developer if an app is involved. Confusion and missing information are often changes you can make yourself in the Wix Editor or Shopify's theme editor. Distractions are the quickest of all, since removing something takes minutes.

Keep the sheet. After your next big change, such as a new design, a new menu or a new product line, run the checklist on 20 fresh visits and compare the two sheets.

Frequently asked questions

What are the signs of user frustration on a website?

The clearest signs are repeated clicks or taps on one spot, menus opened and closed without a choice, and quick trips back and forth between two pages. Fields tapped and left empty, forms started and never sent, and visits that end right after an error are signs too. One sign alone can be chance, so count how often each one repeats across visits.

What is the difference between usability testing and session recording?

Usability testing gives people you chose tasks to do while you watch, so you can ask what they were thinking; session recording shows real visitors doing whatever they came to do, with nobody guiding them. Testing tells you more about reasons, and recordings show natural behavior across many visits. They work well together, as the guide to finding usability problems on a small website shows.

Can a team review session recordings together?

Yes. Split the 20 visits between people and use the same spreadsheet columns. Each person stars the replays behind their rows and writes down the visit's date, start time and the moment. Anyone with access to Session Recordings, in your Shopify admin or Wix dashboard, can then open it, go to the Starred tab and find the visit by its start time. Meet briefly afterwards to merge repeated findings and agree on the top three fixes.

Try it on your site

Session Recordings' 2,000 free recordings a month cover a first batch of 20 many times over, with every feature included. See what's free.

Session Recordings Free forever on Shopify and Wix

Sources

Written by the myuser.ai team

We build marketing apps for online stores: myuser.ai writes and sends emails and texts from a store's own products, and we make Session Recordings and Spin Wheel, free apps for online stores. Product details in our guides are checked against the apps themselves.

See your next visit through your visitor's eyes

Install it on Shopify and switch it on in your theme, or add it to your Wix site. Recording starts with your next visitor.

Add to Shopify Add to Wix Free forever · Shopify and Wix · Form typing masked in the browser